Skip to Content

5 Best 4 Slice Toaster And Buying Guide In 2024

There is a saying that time lost can never be recovered. This saying is indisputably true, and that is why sometimes it is always necessary to save time if possible. Having the best 4 slice toaster is quite an advantage because if you have one, you can do double the work you will do with a 2-slice toaster.

If you are rushing for time, the Cuisinart CPT-435 Countdown 4-Slice Stainless Steel Toaster is our recommendation for the best 4 Slice Toaster. Read further for our detailed product review.

If the toaster has a wider slot, then the better it is. This is because you can toast bread slices of varying sizes. A toaster is among the basic appliances you need in your kitchen. In the market, there a variety of four-slice toasters whose features vary across the board.

Here are some of the best 4 slice toasters that you can find in the market now.

Best Overall

Cuisinart CPT-435 Countdown 4-Slice Stainless Steel ToasterCuisinart CPT-435 Countdown 4-Slice Stainless Steel Toaster


  • Its housing is made of stainless steel material
  • Blue backlit countdown display which makes it attractive.
  • Wide slots of one and a half inches.
  • An easy to remove crumb tray.
  • Blue LED buttons.
  • Has a variety of options such as the defrost, reheat and bagel as well as seven shade settings.

This one is the ideal deals when it comes to 4 slice toasters. It has all the features you could be looking for in a toaster such as the defrost, reheat and bagel. The reheat function will not get your toast or bagel burnt.

It is made of stainless steel material which is easy to clean and rust resistant. Its slots are wide enough to give you the pleasure of putting anything you want such as frozen pancakes, bagels, and toast.

Your fingers will barely get burnt as you grab the toast from the heater, thanks to the Hi-lift lever which lifts the toast higher for you to pick it uncomfortable. It leaves my bagels crispy at the top and chewy at the bottom.


  • The hi-lift lever to lift the toast higher.
  • Ensures that the toasting is consistent.
  • Easy to store as it has a great cord wrap beneath it.
  • Cool exterior made of stainless steel.
  • Appealing appearance.
  • Its countdown feature will let you know how much time is remaining for your toast to be ready


  • Using it is difficult. Learning how it operates will take you some time.
  • Pricier compared to the other toasters reviewed.
  • Has a loud beep, not great to use when other members of the household are asleep.

Best Budget

Cuisinart CPT-142 Compact 4-Slice Toaster


  • Made of plastic material on the exterior
  • Has defrost, bagel and reheat functions
  • Its toasting slots are wide with a one and a half-inch width
  • Works with level 7 settings
  • Its crumb tray easily slides out

This toasting buddy is made of plastic. Its appearance is not what I would call attractive but white color makes it ideal for the kitchen appearance. It has features such as the reheat, cancel, bagel, and defrost options.

See also  10 Best Electric Mixer for Baking And Buying Guide

Its slots are wide enough to accommodate wide slices and also has a high lift lever feature. Its performance on bagels is good as it has level 7 settings. The bagels turned out to be awesome, with their tops having a crispy feel and the bottom chewy.


  • Its exterior has a very simple design
  • Fitted with removable trays which are wide enough and easy to clean.
  • Has defrost, bagel and reheat functions which will make your work easier when using it.
  • Has an H- Lift lever that lifts the toast to ease removal, this will save your time.


  • Its plastic exterior is not suitable. The heat will in the long-run effect the plastic material.
  • Its level 7 settings make the toasts and bagels not to be evenly toasted.

Best 4 slice toaster For Bagels

Hamilton Beach 4 Slice Cool Touch Toaster


  • Has a multi-toasting function.
  • Has a crumb tray which is convenient. You can easily remove it for easy and effective cleaning.
  • Two crumb trays that are convenient and function separately.
  • Wide slots of 1.5 inches. They work well with waffles, hand-sliced bread as well as bagels which are thick.
  • Automatic toast boost.
  • Has a cool-touch exterior that enables you to move your toaster conveniently.

If you are looking for an easy to use 4-slice toaster, look no further. The Hamilton Beach 4-Slice Cool Touch Toaster is practical in appearance. It has two sections, and each is operated separately.

This gives you an opportunity to make some toast in the first tray and some bagel in the other tray. It’s crumb trays are big and can be easily removed. It has the frozen toast option and the frozen bagel option.

To add to that, it has five power levels. With this device, you do not have to worry about getting your hands burnt because it has a cool touch outside. Its features are quite appealing.


  • Has a stylish appearance.
  • You can use one section of this toaster as both of its sections have been separated and are controlled separately.
  • Allows the use of a ticker toast since it has wide trays and a practical design.
  • Enhances even browning.
  • Its automatic toast boost protects your fingers from getting burnt.


  • Some crumbs stray from the tray. This makes cleaning the slice toaster difficult.
  • The slots are not long enough

Hamilton Beach 4-Slice Long Slot Keep Warm Toaster


  • Has wide and tall slots into which wide and long slices of bread can fit.
  • Has a keep warm option which allows your toast or bagels to stay warm for up to three minutes.
  • For easy removal, the toaster has a toast boost feature
  • Has an under-base cord wrap
  • Have rounded buttons with backlight

Its stylish design will certainly attract you. Its buttons have a backlight and are nicely rounded. Its slots are wide and tall, which gives you the liberty to toast big pieces of bread. This is what makes me love the Hamilton Beach 4-Slice Toaster more.

See also  12 Best Cookie Press Reviews And Buying Guide 2023

It’s kept warm option makes the toaster a better option. It can keep your toast warm three minutes after you toast it. What is not practical about this toaster is that it has its cord attached at the front of the toaster. Generally, it is a great appliance to have in your kitchen.


  • Its slots do accommodate big pieces of bread since they are deep and wide.
  • Has a keep warm option which will keep your bagels or toast warm for three more minutes.
  • The toast boost feature protects your fingers from getting burnt.
  • Its rounded buttons have a backlight.


  • The trays cannot be used separately
  • Its design is not practical since the cord faces the front of the toaster while the tray faces the rear of the toaster.
  • At the top, the toaster has a recessed rim which has a plastic trim which catches bread crumbs, making it easy to clean.

Best 4 slice toaster Under $100

Oster TSSTTRWF4S 4-Slice Toaster


  • Wide slots which accommodate slices of varying sizes.
  • Easy to store as it is fitted with a retractable cord.
  • Its settings are suitable for a variety of functions such as reheat, frozen, bagel and cancel.
  • The crumb tray is removable and is dishwasher friendly.
  • Suitable for light to dark toasting, thanks to the 7 toast shade settings

This is an analog toaster that has the bagel, reheat, cancel and frozen options. It is fitted with a retractable cable which is far much better especially when you have to move your Oster 4-Slice Toaster from the kitchen.

Its crumb tray can be easily removed. This makes the cleaning work simpler. If you are toasting small pieces of bread, its lever helps you by lifting them higher. You only need to be cautious with the toast and bagels to ensure that they rest perfectly within the guides. This helps a great deal to prevent your toast from burning.


  • Its cable is retractable. This makes moving it easy.
  • The hi-lift lever to lift smaller pieces higher. This prevents your fingers from getting burnt.
  • Simple to work with.
  • Wide enough slots in which you can toast slices of varying sizes.
  • Encased in stainless steel material which makes it easy to clean and enhances its appearance.


  • Does not toast evenly always.
  • Needs a lot of care especially when placing the toasts. If they are not within the guides, they will definitely get burnt.
  • The levers functioning is not the same. One is better than the other.

Features To Look Out For When Buying A Four-Slice Toaster

Let me give you an overview of what you should look out for when purchasing the best 4 slice toaster that will meet your expectations.

1. Size Of The Slots

Getting a four-slice toaster with wide slots is better. The ideal size of the slots should be one and a half inches wide. The big slots are better compared to the smaller ones because you can toast slices of varying sizes.

2. Materials Used To Make The Toaster

The ideal materials for making slice toasters are aluminum, stainless steel, and plastic. You will certainly be spoilt for choice on knowing which one to buy. I would advise you to go for one with a casing made of stainless steel.

See also  5 Best Meat Injector And Buying Guide In 2024

3. Removable Tray

After preparing a meal, there is time for cleaning. If your slice toaster has a removable tray, cleaning it will be quite easy. You can wash it in a dishwasher to achieve the best results. Most crumb trays are dishwasher friendly.

4. Keep Warm Function

Having a slice toaster with a keep-warm function is a very wise idea. Even when you need to leave in a hurry very early in the morning, you will still have some warm toasts for breakfast. This will help in saving the time you might need to warm the warming the toasted bread.

5. Defrost Function

Most toasters do have the defrost option. You are at liberty to choose from those with universal defrost or those with separate defrost function for toast and bagels. Depending on an individual’s personal preferences, you can go either type of toasters.

6. Cool Touch Exterior

After preparing meals, I love returning every equipment and utensil to its rightful place. A slice toaster with a cool touch exterior helps me to return my toaster at its rightful place even with the inner slots being warm.

7. Toast Boost

This option is ideal. You can comfortably let the children toast their slices, probably when you are not at home or when you are doing some other work. You can be sure that their pretty little fingers will not get burnt.

8. Cord Wrap Or Retracting Cable

For those who place their toaster in another place other than the counter, this feature will serve you best. It is therefore ideal to consider this feature is you know that you will not be placing your toaster on other surfaces apart from the counter.

Wrapping Up

There are several best 4 slice toasters available on the market right now. These products are from various brands which are coming up with different marketing strategies to outdo the competitors. These brand will try as much as possible to convince you that their products are the best when compared with the products offered by their competitors.

This makes the process of settling on a particular slice toaster and buying it a headache. This is because no one ever wants to purchase a product that will end up failing them within a very short time. Therefore a lot of factors need to come into play in order to be able to select the best product available on the markets.

Fortunately enough, we have simplified everything for you, and now you can be in a position to make the right decision when it comes to buying a 4 slice toaster. The factors that need to be considered have exhaustively been addressed above. We have also informed you about some of the five best products that you should consider when buying the best 4 slice toaster.

While all the slice toasters that we have reviewed above are high-quality products, the Cuisinart CPT-435 Countdown 4-Slice Stainless Steel Toaster is somehow exceptional. It has several high-quality features that you would expect from a high-quality product. It ensures a consistent toasting, is made of stainless steel, has an easy to remove crumb tray among other great features.

We would advise you to consider this product first before considering any other4 slice toaster out there.