Cookies are the ultimate comfort foods for many. These delicious treats are ultimate stress busters. The feeling of eating your homemade cookie vs those store-bought versions is just different. At least you know exactly what ingredients are inside your cookies.
The most frustrating part of baking cookies is scooping cookies out of the dough. I have tried before without a cookie scoop and even though my cookie tastes nice, I still prefer a perfectly rounded dollop of the cookie dough. (call me a perfectionist)
As I have not bought one before, I went on a wild journey and started testing and researching over 23 models and came out with the list of the top 11 best cookie scoops. I will share with you why I choose the Pampered Chef Cookie Scoops Set in a short while.
If your favorite dessert is a cookie and if you love baking them at home instead of purchasing from a store, then you can consider investing in good baking accessories.
With a plethora of options available in the market, you may find it difficult to shortlist a tool as per your kitchen needs. Since I have already done my homework, I will also share what are some major factors you have to consider before buying the best cookie scoop in the market. This will be most helpful if you are getting a cookie scoop for the 1st time
Best Cookie Scoops Table Comparison
|Best Overall - Pampered Chef Cookie Scoops Set|
|Best Budget - OXO Good Grips Cookie Scoop|
|Best Runner Up - Jenaluca Cookie Scoop Set|
- Durable high-quality stainless steel makes long term good investment
- Easy use one hand scoop design saves time and energy
- Three sizes to make consistent store quality cookies
- Can be used to scoop ice cream, cookies, melon balls, truffle, and cupcakes
- Dishwasher safe for fast and easy cleaning
Oh, yeah right. I know you must be saying I am out of my mind for recommending a cookie scoop set that costs close to a hundred bucks when there are so many cheapo ones out there. I got the Pampered Chef Cookie Scoops Set for myself and honestly have some buyer remorse until I started using it.
I just loved the quality of the scoops which seem to be made of heavy gauge metal and holding it makes me feels like the Best Baker in America.
Have accidentally dropped it a few times and it doesn’t seem to be damaged at all. This will be a really good return of investment if it can last me a long time since I am quite a frequent baker.
It is so easy for me to scoop my cookie dough and release it with just one hand which saves time and energy. And now I can choose between 3 sizes for papa bear, mama bear, and naughty bear and make store quality cookies to impress my neighbors. What I liked is that I can also use them to scoop ice cream, melon balls, truffles, and cupcakes.
One last thing if you hated washing like me, these high-quality cookie scoops are dishwasher safe too. If you are on a tight budget and maybe only need one cookie scoop size to complement the existing ones, you may like to consider my #2 review for OXO Good Grips cookie scoop below.
- Stainless steel scoop
- One Handed Use
- Three great sizes
- Dishwasher Safe
- It may seem a bit pricey but if you want the best professional cookie scoop for your baking needs this is the one
- The handle is soft and comfortable to manage
- Handle is spring-loaded which absorbs pressure while squeezing and releasing the dough
- The medium scoop can hold 1.5 tablespoons of dough
If you are baking a batch of cookies, then it is best to scoop out uniform dough. This ensures that the entire batch bakes evenly and consistently. The OXO Good Grips cookie scoop is perfect for individuals who want to bake their cookies to perfection. This scoop is available in both small and large sizes.
The medium size scoop roughly cuts out 1 ½ tablespoon of dough. This yields a cookie that is roughly 2 ¾ inches in diameter. The handles of the scoop have been spread a bit wide so that they can be managed easily even with small hands. The soft grips promise comfort even while squeezing. You can also get the larger and smaller cookie scoop if you prefer to have various sizes.
Personally, I find it more convenient to just get the full cookie set like the Pampered Chef Cookie Scoops Set mentioned above.
Cleaning is a breeze when you opt for OXO Good Grips cookie scoop. This kitchen tool is dishwasher safe. This scoop can also be used for scooping out rice, ice cream, and other foods. If you do not like this cookie scoop with limited features, you may like to check out my #3 review below for the Jenaluca Cookie Scoop Set which offers best value for money
- Promises uniform baking
- Is dishwasher safe
- Cleanly ejects sticky dough
- The gear system gets jammed with regular use and may not be suitable for heavy usage compared to Pampered Chef Cookie Scoops Set or Jenaluca cookie scoop set
Best Runner Up
- Lightweight suitable for everyday usage
- Has been designed from food-safe premium stainless steel for health safety
- Serves multiple uses including scooping ice cream, cookies or melon balls, etc
- Various size options to create professional cookies at home
If you are looking for chef-quality tools, then you should consider investing in the Jenaluca cookie scoop set. This cookie scoop is a great option for those who want to bake perfectly round cookies. This scoop has been designed from superior quality stainless steel.
The scooper is light and does not feel heavy while using. It glides smoothly and does not add much pressure to your wrist. This tool can be used by both left and right-handers with the same efficiency. This scooper would not rust or corrode owing to the use of high-quality material in designing.
The best thing about this scoop set is that it is dishwasher safe. It is available in different sizes. You can opt for the size that fits your requirements. This chef-quality tool is reliable and easy to use. All you need to do is scoop, squeeze and release. The ergonomic design of this tool will make it easier for you to manage it.
- Heavy-duty scooper
- Would not rust, corrode or pit
- Mirror polished
- Is dishwasher safe
- Offered in a plush velvet bag which would make it a perfect gift for housewarming, wedding or bridal shower
- felt the Cookie dough releasing mechanism is not as good as the Pampered Chef Cookie Scoops Set but they both have equally good features.
Best Professional Cookie Scoops
Norpro Stainless Steel Cookie Scoops
- Made from high-grade stainless steel
- Features a high polished finish
- Set of three stainless steel scoops
- Heavy-duty spring action
- Releases food effortlessly
This set of Norpro Stainless steel three scoops is ideal for scooping cookie dough, ice cream, for making meatballs, melon or fruit balls. It has been designed with high polished stainless steel. This product has been offered by a reliable brand Norpro that has been offering quality services since 1973.
Norpro’s offering is innovative and a classic example of superior craftsmanship. The spring mechanism of this scooper ensures that you do not have to exert much pressure on your hands.
- Can be used for scooping dough, ice cream, meatballs, melon balls and a lot more
- Easy to use and clean
- Is heavy and sturdy
- Mechanism works smoothly
- Is not dishwasher safe
- The metal has sharp edges
Solula Professional Medium Cookie Scoop
- Scoops cookies of diameter 2 ¾”
- Cookie bakes evenly and is of consistent size
- Release the dough with a single squeeze
- The grip fits comfortably in both the hands
- Has been designed to last for a long time
- Made from 18/8 stainless steel
Solula cookie scoop has been designed to offer flawless service for years. Squeezing the handles to release the dough and ice cream is quite effortless. The spring remains intact after a busy scooping session. The gears slide smoothly to offer hassle service. It has been designed from premium quality stainless steel and will not corrode with frequent use.
You can use the scooper for numerous applications such as scooping fruits, meatballs, ice cream and a lot more. The cookies scooped are of even shape and size. The product is dishwasher safe as it is designed from stainless steel. This product is more than a cookie scooper and promises reliable service for years.
The best thing about Solula professional cookie scoop is that it is backed with 2-year replacement warranty by the makers. You can request for a replacement if the model purchased by you gives away within two years from the date of purchase.
- Durable product that is also dishwasher safe
- Promises multiple uses
- Can be used for scooping sorbet, melon, ice cream, fruit, meat and a lot more
- Info on usage and maintenance of the scoop has not been specified clearly by the makers
Best Stainless Steel Cookie Scoops
Saebye Cookie Scoop Set
- Made from food-grade 18/8 stainless steel
- Made from food-safe material
- Consists of a secondary polishing and has a gleaming surface
- Premium cookie scoop is durable and strong
- Ideal for scooping both soft and hard ice creams, melons and cookies
- Comfortable handles and ergonomic design
This cookie scoop set is available in three different sizes for meeting the requirements of the users. The small size scoop has a diameter of 1.6 inches. The medium size scoop has diameter of 2 inches and the large size scoop has diameter of 2.4 inches. You can use the scoopers as per your requirements for scooping muffins, cupcakes, cookies, meatballs, fruit, and sorbet.
This cookie scoop has been made from high quality 18/8 stainless steel. The scoop has a gleaming surface that has been made from food-grade material. It is safe to use and would not release any harmful chemicals that may leach into your food. This cookie scoop set is easy to use and comes with an ergonomic trigger.
The H-Min scoop comes with a trigger and would release filler and would save much intense effort for your hand and wrist. The handles have been thoughtfully designed and do not require you to put in great hand strength. This scooper serves multiple purposes and would make a great versatile tool in your kitchen.
Saebye Cookie Scoop is easy to clean. It can also be cleaned in a dishwasher. The product is 100 percent recyclable. It does have little plastic parts. The stainless steel scoop is stain and rust-resistant.
- No spring release system
- Durable product and easy to use
- Features an innovative cog-and-ratchet design
- Doesn’t require you to put in intense effort on your wrist and hand
- Thoughtfully designed handles and trigger system
- Versatile kitchen tool
- Using on hard things such as sub-zero ice cream can shorten its lifespan
Kitchenaid KN148OHSBA Gourmet Cookie Dough Scoop
- Offers uniform balls of cookie dough, metal balls, and fruits
- Made from durable stainless steel
- Soft grip handles for durability and comfort
- Easy to squeeze the handle
- Spring-loaded mechanism
A KitchenAid cookie scoop is a perfect tool for a baker. It will make you feel like a professional. It is available in bright and popular colors. The product has been crafted with premium materials and will last for a long time.
The best thing about this cookie dough scoop is that it is backed with one-year hassle-free replacement warranty and also by lifetime limited warranty.
This cookie dough scoop has been warranted to be free from defects in workmanship and materials. This gourmet cookie dough scoops uniform balls of melon for fruit salad, ground beef for meatballs and cookie dough for cookies. This tool is simple and easy to use. The soft-grip handle makes it easier to handle this tool. This product is also dishwasher safe.
- Scoop measures 1.5 tablespoons of dough
- Is dishwasher safe
- Backed by 1-year hassle-free replacement and lifetime limited warranty by the makers
- Easy to use
- Cookie ball tends to stick inside the scooper
Hiware 18/8 Cookie Scoop
- Helps you achieve perfect sized and uniform cookies
- Easy to clean and use
- Is dishwasher safe
- Durable design
- Made from 18/8 stainless steel
This Hiware stainless steel cookie dough scoop promises uniform balls of cookie dough every time you use it. This versatile product can be used for scooping meatballs, melon balls and also cookie dough. If you simply dislike baking uneven cookies, then this is the tool you can use for your assistance.
You can cut cookie doughs like a pro with Hiware 18/8 cookie scoop. This tool has a stainless steel body and it promises good grip handle to the users. This multipurpose tool cuts out even portions of food that you can manage with it.
- Features a mirror polish on the surface
- Great spring action
- Good grip over the handle
- Releases food easily
- Scoop doesn’t function with extremely soft cookie doughs
Best Quality Cookie Scoops
Homure H Cookie Scoop Set
- Includes large, medium and small cookie scoop
- Features an ergonomic trigger system
- Scoops easily and gently
- Is absolutely safe to use
- Made of food-grade 18/8 stainless steel
This cookie scoop set features a thickened spoon ball and handle. The best thing about this set is that it would last for a long time without bending or breaking. The cookie scoops in this set feature 18/8 stainless steel. It also has a shiny appearance because of the coating.
Homure H cookie scoop set can be used for numerous purposes in home kitchens. You can scoop out ice creams, meatballs and cookie doughs effortlessly with this multipurpose scoop. The set consists of three scoopers: small, medium and large size. The trigger is ergonomic, efficient and practical.
The scooper can relieve pressure on the wrist and hand while scooping and releasing the cookie dough. It cleans easily and is also dishwasher safe. It would not corrode or rust in comparison to inferior stainless steel.
- Is heavier than other metallic scoops
- Is durable and food safe tool
- Is dishwasher safe
- Can be used for numerous purposes
- Movement is not smooth
- The design is flimsy
JSdoin Cookie Scoop Set
- Features an ergonomic trigger design
- Simple squeeze releases cookie dough
- Glides easily over the dough
- Does not require you to put intense effort while scooping
- Grip offered is secure and comfortable
This cookie scoop set is one of the most elegant cookie scooper available in the market. It glides smoothly over the dough and does not require you to put in an intense effort. The grip offered to the users is secure. You can manage it comfortably by either left or right hand.
JSdoin cookie scoop set has been designed to last. This scoop set has been designed from 18/8 stainless steel which would not discolor or chip. This tool is durable and safe to use. It is easy to clean and is also dishwasher safe. Handwashing is however recommended by the makers to prevent retain the glister.
This quality product would offer you beautiful scoops of ice cream or any other food item that you desire. The set consists of small size, medium-size and large size scoopers. This elegant kitchen gadget would make a perfect gift as well.
- Made from 18/8 stainless steel
- Would not chip or discolor
- Is safe and durable
- Is dishwasher safe
- Versatile kitchen tool
- Beautifully designed
- Falls apart if not handled appropriately
Saebye Small Cookie Scoop
- Small size, heavy-duty scoop
- High-quality scoop made from 18/8 stainless steel
- Features a gleaming surface
- Is durable and safe to use
- Does not consist of any harmful chemicals
- Easy to use
- Features newly designed, innovative cog-and-ratchet
- Thoughtfully designed handles
This cookie scoop has been designed from high grade 18/8 stainless steel. The material used is of food-grade and is safe to use in direct contact with food. This metal ice cream scoop has a gleaming surface because of secondary polishing. This cookie scoop is durable and strong.
You can use Saebye small cookie scoop for scooping soft and hard ice creams, melons, cookies and a lot more. It is advised not to use it on hard things such as sub-zero ice cream. This may cut down its lifespan. The design of this cookie scoop is ergonomic. The handles are comfortable and would fit comfortably in your hands.
You can utilize the trigger scoop for releasing the food item. You do not have to put intense efforts for releasing the scooped food. The no spring action mechanism can release the scoop effortlessly. This scoop is easy to use and would last for a long time.
- Ergonomic release system
- Does not require any intense effort or hand strength
- Serves multiple purposes
- Is dishwasher safe and also environmental friendly
- Is 100 percent recyclable
- Doesn’t have any plastic part
- Scoop is stain resistant and would not corrode, rust or pit
- Tends to rust with regular use
Factors to consider before purchasing a cookie scoop
There are a lot of factors that can influence your decision of making a purchase. With a plethora of options available in the market, it can be difficult for you to shortlist a product. You can look into the following criteria to choose the best product available in the market currently.
The most critical factor to look into while looking for a cookie scoop is its built. It is best to opt for stainless steel or any metallic scooper. The sturdiness would ensure that the cookie scooper would last for a long time without giving away. Look into the durability of the material to derive the best from the product.
Ease of usage
Scoopers are frequently used tools in the kitchen. These are versatile products and can be used for a plethora of purposes. It is best to go for products that are easy to use and feature ergonomic design. Ergonomic designing increases the efficiency of a product and also ensures that a task is accomplished with minimal effort.
Design of the handle
One of the most vital aspects of choosing a cookie scoop is to look into the handle design. These are responsible for accomplishing the scooping action and hence care must be exercised to consider the material of the handle. The scoopers available in the market usually feature handles made from ceramic, plastic, aluminum and stainless steel. Opt for handles that are comfortable to hold. Spring-loaded handles absorb pressure and let you dig deeper into any bowl for obtaining a full scoop.
Dimensions of the scoop
Cookie scoops are usually available in three sizes. You can opt for small, medium or large cookie scoop depending on your requirements. Small cookie scoops usually offer cookies that are two inches in diameter. Medium cookie scoops offer three-inch cookies and large scoops offer cookies of four inches. Opt for a size that is best suited for your needs.
How do you scoop the perfect cookie?
While it is hard to turn down imperfectly shaped cookies, it is good to try to make then round if possible, especially if you plan to give them out or serve them during a party. Thankfully, there are different ways to make all of them look the same including:
Improvise a sling
Slice-and-bake or icebox cookies are usually made by rolling the dough to form a log. Then it is left to chill and firm up well before it is sliced and baked. Even with a seamlessly round log, it will end up flattening out when in the freezer or fridge. Combat this easily using cardboard by placing the roll at the center of a paper towel. Cut it open using scissors, put the dough inside, and chill it. the result will be perfectly round.
Use round cutters
Ring molds or round cutters can be used to make seamlessly round cookies from a rolled-out dough. This method is especially good when preparing sandwich cookies. You will get cookies that are the same in size and shape.
Cookies or ice cream scoops
There is no better tool to use when looking to make drop cookies than a small cookie or ice cream scoops. Fill your scoop with the prepared dough, remove the excess on the sides of the bowl. Then press lightly and release it to the baking sheets. All the cookies will be round with the same size.
Roll smooth balls from the dough
This method does not need any tool at all. Gently roll the dough in your hands to make round balls before it is baked. It will work best for smooth doughs because the chunky ones will need you to slightly apply some pressure. The cookies produced will look quite perfect and better than the ones dropped using spoons.
Other Related FAQs About Cookie Scoop
What is the best size for a cookie scoop?
Well, numbers are necessarily helpful everywhere and when it comes to scooping of cookie dough there is no exception. The good thing is that the market offers different sizes of cookie scoops to suit everyone’s needs. From tablespoon to dish sizes you can choose just what you feel will be accommodating what you want.
It is worth noting that the tools are versatile there is no reference for the best one. However, the bigger it is the better because it will be giving you a higher volume. When looking for the tools it would be just fine to get more than one size since all are likely very helpful if you frequently bake.
How much does a cookie scoop hold?
Cookie scoops are meant to make baking such a breeze. From drop-cookies to pizzelles and scones you will get a snack with some nice shape and uniform size. A generous tablespoon-sized one holds about four teaspoons of dough. It is good to keep in mind that this measure is not exact, but it is sized to reflect the estimated amount that a baker will get when you choose to use the usual tablespoon used during dinner for scooping your cookie dough.
If you need one for a food service size, it is good to get a suitable one. For your baking needs just look for the actual imprinted scoop number first for easy cookie results having equivalent volume.
Scoops size cookies because the small cookie scoop holds about two teaspoons of dough.
What is the size of a scoop?
The sizes of cookie scoops are such a perplexing thing. The reason is that it affects the size of what is being baked. They are range from small to medium, and even large. But what does this mean when a one is mentioned in the recipe you wish to make?
A small one can yield a cookie with a diameter that is around 2 inches. Meanwhile, the medium size will make cookies about 3-inches while the large scoops make cookies of 4-inches Well if the instructions call for one tablespoon of cookie dough and you plan to use a scoop, it will be good to use the right size. The good thing is that the number is usually written on the sides to make the process of measuring quite easier.
What can I use instead of a cookie scoop?
In case you do not have cookie scoops it does not mean you cannot make the perfect sized cookies. When baking drop cookies, you can substitute the usual cookie scoop for a spoon. Even better you can choose to have sticky fingers. Go for what you find to be your favorite way of scooping especially.
Spoons work best if the dough is quite chunky because of fillers that cannot easily fit into your cookie scoop. The reason is that they are well shaped and are shallow enough. So, you will not have to struggle to remove it. Or you can try using a small-sized measuring cup for jumbo cookies. Then drop the prepared dough to baking sheets effortlessly. You don’t need to dig it out. The cup might need to be sprayed from the inside in between every cookie drops.
How many tablespoons are in a cookie scoop?
Getting the right amount of cookie scoop from a tablespoon can be far from your thoughts if you are just starting your baking sessions. However, as your skills improve you will learn how to use the alternatives for various goods especially if you do not have a scoop. Sure, no kitchen misses having regular dinner spoons and that is enough for measuring cookie dough portions. The reality is that getting it accurately done can be tough.
Scoops are identified using a number. And this typically denotes the number of leveled measures that it takes to create one quart. The measurements that a tablespoon has for a cookie scoop differ with the manufacturer. So, with the one having the number 16, a meticulous baker will measure 16 times. Generally, it is still possible to have a precise count even without a scoop.
Wrap For Best Cookie Scoops
You need to carry out research for ensuring that you invest in nothing but the best products. Based on the factors to consider we mentioned above, our top choice for the best cookie scoop will still be the Pampered Chef Cookie Scoops Set .
If you are looking for a quality cookie scoop, you will have to make sure to look into the material of construction and spring action mechanism for investing in the best model available in the market. This will ensure that you make the right decision while opting for any product as per your requirements.